To Be a Girl

“I thought growing up would fix everything.” Priya Shah on being watched, being told she is too much, and why a girl’s anger in India is not weakness but memory.

Cite this piece

When I was a child, I thought I would grow up and break the mould, create my own reality and be free. I thought growing up would fix everything.

I believed adulthood came with freedom like birthdays came with cake. automatic, guaranteed. I thought once I crossed the invisible line into being an adult, the world would somehow treat me differently. That it would see that I had endured eighteen years of being watched, judged, misread and stared at. Eighteen years of learning to be careful with my body, my voice, my clothes, my timing, my laughter.

I thought maybe after all that, the world would hand me equality like something overdue.

Growing up as a girl in India meant learning early that the world is always looking at you. Not in a kind way. Not in a curious way. In a way that makes you feel like you are on display even when you are just trying to exist.

You feel it in small moments first.
The man who stares too long when you walk past a shop.
The stranger who stands too close in a crowded bus.

The comments whispered loudly enough for you to hear but quietly enough that no one else will react.

At first, you don’t even have words for it, something just feels innately wrong.

And then slowly you learn the rules. Rules no one writes down but everyone expects you to follow.

Don’t walk alone at night.
Don’t laugh too loudly.
Don’t wear something that will “invite attention.”
Don’t talk back to older men.
Don’t be rude.
Don’t be difficult.

The list grows with every growing candle on your birthday.

For a while I believed if I followed those rules carefully enough, things would get better. I believed if I did everything right, the world would meet me halfway.

So when I finally started asking for space, for fairness, for basic respect, I expected people to understand.

Instead, I was told I was too much.

Too opinionated.
Too loud.
Too aggressive.
Too emotional.

Apparently a girl who asks for dignity is exhausting.

The strange thing is that the criticism rarely comes all at once. It builds slowly. One comment here. One raised eyebrow there. Someone calling you “intense” when you refuse to laugh at something sexist. Someone telling you to calm down when you are simply explaining why something feels wrong.

After a while you start wondering if maybe they’re right.

Maybe you are too much.

So I tried running the other way.

I softened my voice. I stopped arguing. I learned how to smile politely even when something made my skin crawl with disgust. I tried to be the kind of girl people describe as “easygoing.”

I made myself smaller.

And nothing changed.

The staring didn’t stop. The comments didn’t stop. The assumptions didn’t stop.

If anything, silence seemed to give people permission.

It felt like living inside a glass cage. Everyone could see me, but I had no control over what they saw. People projected whatever they wanted onto me — innocence, arrogance, flirtation, weakness — and somehow it was always my responsibility to correct their imagination.

When I stayed quiet, people assumed I didn’t mind.
When I didn’t protest, they assumed I liked the attention.

When I chose not to create a scene, they assumed nothing wrong had happened.

Silence became another thing the world used against me.

There is a particular kind of exhaustion that comes with being a girl here. It isn’t just fear. It isn’t just frustration. It’s the constant awareness that your existence is being evaluated.

Your clothes are evaluated.
Your safety is debated.
Your character is speculated about.

Everyone seems to have an opinion about how a girl should behave, but very few people seem interested in asking how it actually feels to live inside that body.

By the time I turned eighteen and started living alone, I thought things would finally change. I imagined independence would feel like stepping into open air after years in a crowded room.

Instead I discovered something unsettling.

Freedom is not automatically given to women. It has to be negotiated every day.

Every decision becomes a calculation.

Is it safe to take this road?
Should I call someone so they know where I am?
Will this outfit become a conversation I never asked for?

The world still felt like it was watching.

That was the year I became angry.

Not the loud, explosive anger people expect. Something quieter. Heavier. The kind that settles deep in your chest and refuses to leave.

Anger at being watched.

Anger at how easily girls are reduced to bodies before they are recognized as people.

Anger at a culture that tells girls to shrink themselves and then criticizes them for lacking confidence.

Anger at how quickly responsibility shifts. When something happens to a girl, the first question is rarely “Who did this?” It is almost always “Why was she there?” or “What was she wearing?” or “Why didn’t she say something?”

Somehow the burden always circles back to us.

And the strange thing about anger is that society doesn’t know what to do with angry women.

An angry man is passionate.
An angry woman is difficult.

An angry man is strong.
An angry woman is unstable.

So girls learn to bury their anger too. To smile through it. To turn it into jokes or sarcasm or silence.

But anger doesn’t disappear just because you hide it.

It stays.

It sits quietly inside you every time someone dismisses your experience. Every time someone explains your own reality back to you as if you misunderstood it. Every time you see another girl blamed for something that was never her fault.

Today, when I say I am angry at the world because I am a girl, I don’t mean that anger as a weakness.

I mean it as memory.

It carries every stare, every comment, every moment of shrinking. It carries the years of being told to behave instead of being told we deserved better.

And maybe anger is not the worst thing.

Maybe anger is the beginning of refusing to accept the cage.
And me, I am still learning to negotiate my freedom everyday.

How to cite this piece

OSCOLA

Priya Shah, ‘To Be a Girl’ (Vox Populi, 11 October 2026) <https://vox-populi-nine.vercel.app/articles/to-be-a-girl> accessed 17 November 2026.

Bluebook

Priya Shah, To Be a Girl, Vox Populi (Oct. 11, 2026), https://vox-populi-nine.vercel.app/articles/to-be-a-girl.

More in Human Rights
Tech & Privacy Article

Artificial Intelligence and Copyright Law: A Legal Grey Area

When Machines Create: Who Owns the Copyright? Artificial intelligence is transforming creativity, but who owns what machines produce? This article explores the legal grey areas surrounding AI-generated content, copyright ownership, training data and infringement under Indian law. It examines emerging judicial developments and proposes legislative reforms to balance technological innovations.

Suvidhi Jain 17 min read
Criminal Long-form Analysis

Marital Rape in India: The Imperative for Criminalization

In India, a husband cannot be charged with raping his wife. Mana Shah argues that the marital rape exemption is legally incoherent, constitutionally unsound, morally indefensible, and deeply harmful to the women it leaves unprotected.

Mana Shah 22 min read

One email, when there is something worth reading.

New pieces and explainers from Vox Populi, straight to your inbox.

No spam. Unsubscribe any time by replying to any email.